Spousal Protection
is a program that increases the likelihood that when one spouse enters a
nursing home, the community spouse will be able to retain a basic amount of
income and resources to meet ongoing living expenses.
This program is only applicable to married couples in one of the following
circumstances:
1. Admission to a Nursing Home. Spousal Protection is appropriate
a) when one person lives in (or is planning to move to) a nursing home for at
least 30 consecutive days beginning on or after 9-1-89 and the other person
lives in the community and
b) the institutionalized spouse is receiving assistance from Medicaid or is
eligible to receive Medicaid for nursing homes expenses.
or
2. Home and Community Based Services. Effective July 1, 1999, Spousal
Protection is appropriate when a spouse is determined to be eligible for home
and community based services and wants to remain at home, instead of moving to
a nursing home.
The Spousal Protection Program a) includes the assessment of a couple's
resources when one spouse becomes institutionalized, for the purpose of
determining at what point the institutionalized spouse will become eligible for
Medicaid, and b) provides for the amount of income which may be contributed by
the Medicaid-eligible institutionalized spouse toward the monthly expenses of
the community spouse and dependent "family members" who reside with the
community spouse.
The Medicaid Estate Recovery Act passed in 1991 allows the State of Colorado
to put a lien on the property of the individual if they have assets and receive
Medicaid in the nursing home. However, if a spouse continues to live in the
house, a lien will not be filed. See Section on Medicaid Estate Recovery Act.
If a transfer of assets for less than fair market value is made within three
years (36 months) of applying for Medicaid (or within five years - 60 months -
if the transfer is into or out of a trust), a penalty period for receiving
Medicaid benefits may be imposed.
WHAT COUNTS AS INCOME?
The institutionalized spouse must be eligible for and receiving Medicaid
support in the nursing home. For 2003, income for the institutionalized spouse
may not exceed $1656 per month. Persons with incomes in excess of $1656 per
month with an approved Medicaid Qualifying Trust may receive Medicaid support
under the Spousal Protection program. Income rules for Supplemental Security
Income apply. Income includes:
* Wages or earnings from a job
* Social Security
* Supplemental Security Income/Old Age Pension
* Pensions (Private or Government)
* Gifts (generally more than $25 in value)
* Interest from investment income
* Income from annuities, regardless of purchase date
* Stocks and bonds
The institutionalized spouse retains the first $50 of his/her income.
The spouse living in the home is not allowed to keep a personal needs allowance.
The balance may be used to supplement the income of the community spouse.
The monthly expenses of the community spouse are the "minimum monthly
maintenance needs allowance" or MMMNA.
Minimum Monthly Maintenance Needs Allowance for the community spouse is
computed as follows:
* Income of $1493 per month
* Amount by which shelter costs exceed 30% of the above income figure
* The total amount of the two items above may not exceed $2267
* Additional amounts of money can be granted to the community spouse for
exceptional circumstances which cause the community spouse significant financial duress
* For each dependent child, who lives with the community spouse, an additional
allowance may be allocated
WHAT DOESN'T COUNT AS INCOME?
* Tax/Rent Rebates
* Any income from the Veterans Administration for aid and attendants and
payments for unusual medical expenses (these funds will be counted for
determining the patient payment to the nursing home)
WHAT ARE COUNTABLE RESOURCES?
* Real Estate (investment, rental or income property)
* Cash
* Checking or Savings Accounts
* Bonds
* Stocks
* Second Car or Recreational Vehicle
* Personal Belongings (such as jewelry or works of art)
* Whole Life Insurance Policies (Cash Value)
* Burial policy (Whole Life)
* Revocable annuities
* Irrevocable Annuities (under some terms and conditions)
Under spousal protection, the community spouse is allowed to retain a
portion of the countable (non-exempt) resources which are owned by the couple
either jointly or individually at the time institutionalization begins. This is
known as the Community Spouse Resource Allowance (CSRA).
The community spouse is allowed to retain a maximum of $90,660 for the
Community Spouse Resource Allocation. The institutionalized spouse is allowed
to retain $2,000. Any amount in excess of $92,660 ($90,660 plus $2,000) is
subject to spousal protection rules.
Couples who have assets over $96,660 must spend down those assets to be
eligible for Medicaid coverage for the nursing home spouse. (See Tips for
Practitioners on ways to spend down)
WHAT RESOURCES ARE EXEMPT (OR DO NOT COUNT)?
* Home in which the community spouse or a dependent child resides
* Car (there is no limit on the market value of a single vehicle)
* Personal belongings (clothing and furniture)
* Medical equipment required by the recipient's physical condition
* Items of individual education
* Items of personal care (such as wheelchair)
* Term Life Insurance Policy
* Burial Policy (irrevocable, or no cash value)
* A revocable burial fund up to $1500 for burial expenses (this will be reduced
by the amount that may be in a life insurance policy)
* Annuities (under some terms and conditions -- see below)
Current Medicaid rules for annuities purchased prior to July 1, 1995:
1. Are exempt resources if annuitized and regular returns are being received.
The funds are counted as part of the MMMNA in the month they are received.
2. If the annuity is purchased by the Medicaid applicant and/or the spouse has not
been annuitized (receiving regular returns), the annuity shall be considered an
available resource regardless of the irrevocable status.
3. The length of time the individual receives a return cannot exceed the individual's
life expectancy based upon tables (see below) in the Medicaid manual.
Current Medicaid rules for annuities purchased on or after July 1, 1995:
1. The purchase shall be a transfer without fair consideration unless the following criteria are met:
a. The annuity is purchased from a life insurance company licensed to sell annuities as part of the business
b. The annuity is annuitized for the Medicaid applicant or the spouse
c. The annuity is purchased on the life of the Medicaid applicant or the spouse
d. The annuity provides payments for a period of time not exceeding the annuitant's projected life (see table below)
Current rules for annuities purchased on or after April 1, 1998:
1. The county department of social services shall determine the Minimum Monthly
Maintenance Needs Allowance (MMMNA) of the community spouse. If the monthly income from
the annuity causes the MMMNA to be over $1493 (or $2267 for hardship), the
amount of the annuity that causes the MMMNA to be over $1493 (or $2267 for hardship) shall be considered a transfer without fair consideration.
For example, if a community spouse a) invested $100,000 in an annuity over and above
the Community Spouse Resource Allocation (CSRA) b) had $600 per month in income from
Social Security and $700 per month from a company pension and the annuity was returning
$450 per month, the MMMNA would be $257 over the allowed amount of $1473. Depending
upon the rate of return of the annuity, approximately $35,000 would be considered a
transfer without fair consideration. Given the penalty rate of $4424 for nursing home
placement, the Medicaid applicant would be ineligible for Medicaid for approximately
7.5 months.
2. The Medicaid applicant or the community spouse must receive substantially equal
installments from the annuity, or it will be considered a transfer without fair
consideration.
To calculate the rate of return for a Straight Life annuity, the Life Expectancy
tables (below) are used to identify the number of years that the individual is expected
to live to determine the term of the Straight Life annuity.
| Resource Limits |
Income Limits |
| 1/1/95 |
CSRA Minimum - n/a
Maximum - $74,820
7/1/96Basic:
$1,254
30% Shelter Allowance
MMMNA: $1,871
Utility Allowance: $174 |
| 1/1/96 |
CSRA Minimum - n/a
Maximum - $76,740
7/1/96Basic:
$1,295
30% Shelter Allowance
MMNA: $1,919
Utility Allowance: $174 |
| 1/1/97 |
CSRA Minimum: n/a
Maximum: $79,020
7/1/97Basic:
$1,327
30% Shelter Allowance
MMMNA: $1,919
Utility Allowance: $174 |
| 1/1/98 |
CSRA Minimum: n/a
Maximum: $80,760
7/1/98Basic:
$1,357
30% Shelter Allowance
MMMNA: $2,049
Utility Allowance: $174 |
| 1/1/99 |
CSRA Minimum: n/a
Maximum: $81,960
Utility Allowance: $174
7/1/99Basic:
$1,383
30% Shelter Allowance
MMMNA: $2,049
Utility Allowance: $174 |
1/1/2000 |
CSRA Minimum: n/a
Maximum: $84,120
MMMNA: $2,103
Utility: $174
7/1/2000 |
Basic: $1,407
30% shelter allowance $469
MMMNA: $2,103
Utility: $174
1/1/2001 |
CSRA Minimum: n/a
Maximum: $87,000
MMMNA: $2,175
Utility: $174
7/1/2001 |
Basic: $1,493
30% Shelter allowance $469
MMMNA: $2,175
Utility: $209
1/1/2002 |
CSRA Minimum: n/a
Maximum: $89,280
MMMNA: $2,232
Utility: $209
WHAT ARE THE ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS?
* For couples who are married, one spouse must live in a nursing home; or one spouse
must be determined to be eligible for Home and Community Based Services after July 1,
2000.
* Individual must be in an institution for at least 30 consecutive days
* Individual must pass the "level of care" screen which certifies that the individual
needs nursing home or hospital care (ULTC 100)
* Income of the institutionalized spouse must be less than 300% of the Supplemental
Security Income level (for 2000, $1656 per month)
* The institutionalized spouse's countable resources must be less than $2,000
* The Community Spouse Resource Allowance or countable resources of the community
spouse can not be more than $90,660
HOW TO APPLY FOR BENEFITS?
Call or visit the local County Department of Social Services, the case management
agency or the Single Entry Point in the County where the nursing home or hospital is
located. Regardless of the amount of resources of the couple and if the income of the
institutionalized spouse is more than $1656, the community spouse should visit the
local County Department of Social Services, the case management agency or Single Entry
Point and request the Community Spouse Resource Allowance be calculated to avoid delays
in future eligibility for Medicaid benefits for the institutionalized spouse.
The local County Department of Social Services, case management agency or Single
Entry Point must assess the couple's resources within 45 days at two points in time
a) when the individual enters an institution; and b) when the institutionalized spouse
applies for Medicaid. A reasonable fee may be charged by the local County Department
of Social Services for the assessment.
WHAT DOCUMENTS ARE REQUIRED TO PROVE ELIGIBILITY?
* Proof of Social Security income
* Proof of income from stocks, bonds, or interest
* Copies of recent bank statements
* Copies of bills or statements for house payments, rent, utilities, property taxes
and insurance
* Maintenance fees charged by condominium associations
* Copies of insurance premiums for health, life, car and burial
* Copies of monthly medical bills
* Other regular monthly expenses of the community spouse
* Proof that no transfer of property has occurred within the previous 36 to 60 months
* Copies of burial policies
HOW MUCH WILL BE RECEIVED FROM SPOUSAL PROTECTION?
The community spouse will receive a maximum of $1473 per month. The community spouse
may receive an additional allowance up to $4480 per month up to a maximum of $2267.
Additional income may be received for dependents and for exceptional circumstances.
TO WHAT OTHER PROGRAMS MIGHT A SPOUSAL PROTECTION RECIPIENT BE ENTITLED?
* Food stamps and other food programs
* Medicaid
* Supplemental Security Income/Old Age Pension
* Pensions (especially veterans benefits)
* Rent/Tax Rebates
* Utility Assistance
* Subsidized Housing
* Burial Assistance
* Emergency Assistance Payments
* Weatherization
* Special Low Income Medicare Benefit
WHAT CHANGES NEED TO BE REPORTED TO THE LOCAL COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL SERVICES, CASE MANAGEMENT AGENCY OR SINGLE ENTRY POINT?
* New mailing address if the community spouse or the institutional spouse moves
* Another individual moves in or out of the household
* Individual goes to work
* Income goes up or down
* Divorce or separation of spouses
* Property is bought or sold, including the home or car
TIPS FOR PRACTITIONERS
1. Asset Transfers to Community Spouse. If the institutionalized spouse is eligible
for Medicaid and the community spouse is not already in possession of assets equal to
the community spouse resource allocation, the assets must be transferred from the
institutionalized spouse to the community spouse within 90 days.
2. Rules prior to 9/30/89. The rules apply for new admissions, as well as those
already residing in a nursing home. If a spouse was in a nursing home prior to September
30, 1989, other rules will apply to resources, but the community spouse should still
apply for Spousal Protection of income.
3. Veterans Benefits. Couples applying for Spousal Protection may be required to
apply for Veterans or other benefits for the institutionalized spouse prior to receiving
a determination of eligibility.
4. Treatment of Income Property. Couples who own income property may be eligible for
Spousal Protection, if the income from the income property is needed to contribute to
the MMMNA (Minimum Monthly Maintenance Needs Allowance).
5. Confidentiality. Spousal protection calculations are usually made from the date
of entry to the nursing home, however, records are usually started at the time
discussions begin with the Single Entry Point, local County Department of Social
Services or Case Management Agency. Therefore, when calling the Single Entry Point,
the local County Department of Social Services or the Case Management Agency, disclose
only the information which is needed. Be sure to protect the confidentiality of your
client if you are only seeking information to determine potential eligibility.
6. Purchasing Burial Policies. Couples who own a whole life insurance policy and who
cash that policy in to purchase a burial plan, marker or plot, may be subject to
private pay to the nursing home during the period the whole life insurance policy is
being redeemed. It may be better to redeem the whole life policy and purchase an
irrevocable burial policy, marker or plot, prior to applying for Medicaid at the
Single Entry Point, Case Management Agency or the local County Department of Social
Services. Unless the institutionalized spouse is receiving Medicare Part A coverage or
is hospitalized during this time period, the individual will be charged at the
private pay rate as part of the spend down of resources. Medicaid benefits are
retroactive to the date of admission to the nursing home, however, records are
usually started at the time of initial discussions with the Single Entry Point,
local County Department of Social Services or the Case Management Agency. If the
individual is going from the private home to the nursing home, it is advisable to
make these changes prior to nursing home placement.
7. Medicaid Qualifying Trust Pay-outs to Community Spouse. In instances where
the institutionalized spouse is the beneficiary of a Medicaid Qualifying Trust and has
been approved for Medicaid benefits, the community spouse may receive Spousal Protection
payments.
8. Medicaid Lien. Individuals who are eligible for Spousal Protection may be subject
to the Medicaid Estate Recovery Act if they own real property. If the community spouse
continues to live in the home, a lien will not be placed on the home. (See Section on
Medicaid Estate Recovery Act). Another way to protect against a lien is to transfer
ownership of the home to the community spouse with a quit claim deed within 90 days
Medicaid benefits having started.
9. How Do You Spend Down?
You may spend down resources in any of the following ways:
* Pay for nursing home care
* Purchase a primary residence and household furnishings
* Purchase items for the nursing home spouse such as a television, clothing, etc.
* Purchase an irrevocable burial policy
* Make home improvements such as a new roof, insulation, refrigerator,etc.
* Pay off indebtedness
* Purchase an annuity (under some terms and conditions)
* Purchase of medical equipment
The following types of transfers are exempt and qualify as a spend down of resources:
* Transfers to the Medicaid recipient's spouse
* Transfers to a child who is determined to be blind or permanently and totally disabled
* Transfers of a home to a) child who is under twenty-one years of age or b) a
sibling who has an equity interest in the home and who has resided in the home for at
least one year immediately before the date the individual becomes institutionalized; or
c) a son or a daughter of any age who was residing in the home for a period of at least
two years immediately before the date the individual becomes institutionalized, and who
provided care to the individual to allow him or her to remain in his or her own home,
rather than in a nursing home
* Purchase of an annuity 36 months prior to a Medicaid application (NOTE: only the income
from the annuity is counted toward the Minimum Monthly Maintenance Needs Allowance - MMMNA).
Transfers to trusts which are exempt and qualify for spend down without a penalty are:
* Supplemental needs trusts which are drafted to provide for the individual's
supplemental care (ie anything that is not covered by public or private benefits,
including, for example, the cost differential between a private and semi-private room,
television, hair care, outings, etc).
* Disability trusts established by a parent, grandparent, legal guardian or court
for a disabled person (as defined under Supplemental Security Income standards) under
age sixty-five, and which designate the state as the remainderman. In addition,
Colorado (unlike the federal regulations) requires that these funds originate from a
personal injury settlement or from Zebley settlements (retroactive SSI benefits paid
pursuant to a class action lawsuit entitled Sullivan v Zebley);
* Pooled Trusts, which are supplemental needs trust set up by non-profit
associations for disabled persons of any age, provided that, the state must be the
remainder man to the extent of medical assistance paid to the Medicaid applicant or
recipient, and, as in the prior example, funds must originate from personal injury or
Zebley settlements.
* Miller Trusts (or Medicaid Qualifying Trusts) which are trusts for individuals
whose income exceeds the state Medicaid income cap, but is less than the average
monthly cost of nursing home care in the geographic region in which the individual
lives. These persons are often referred to as being in the "Utah gap".
* Transfer made prior to 36 months before the Medicaid application is submitted
or 60 months if the transfer is made to a trust.
10. Transfers Without Fair Consideration.
Transfers that are disallowed and do not follow the guidelines above are
considered a Transfer With Fair Consideration (TWFC).
a. To determine eligibility for spousal protection, the rules related to transfer
of property, without receiving fair market value in return are applied. Assets
which have been transferred 36 months prior to application for Medicaid are applied
when determining eligibility for Spousal Protection. These include gifting money
to relatives or friends (although the Internal Revenue Service allows gifts of
$10,000 per year per person to another individual without tax consideration,
Medicaid does not honor these gifting rules); transferring title in rental
property, recreation vehicles or other investment instruments.
b. In some cases, such as trusts, assets which have been transferred during the
past 60 months can be reviewed. If individuals have transferred assets, they may
be subject to a variety of penalties, including loss of Medicaid reimbursements
in the nursing home. The Medicaid applicant may be required to seek a return of
assets which have been transferred to another individual.
c. If a person purchases an irrevocable annuity and transfers the benefit to a
third party (other than the spouse), the entire amount of the annuity would be
considered as a transfer of assets.
d. If a person purchases an annuity that is not irrevocable, the entire amount
of the annuity is considered a countable resource and the person would not be eligible
for Medicaid until the resource was reduced to the allowable resource limit for
Medicaid.
e. Annuities may be considered a transfer of assets without fair consideration.
A transfer without fair consideration has occurred if:
1). The length of time the annuity was purchased exceeds the reasonable life
expectancy of the annuitant using the Life Expectancy Tables above.
2). The amount of money used to purchase the annuity increases the Minimum
Monthly Maintenance Needs Allowance (MMMNA) -- only that portion of the annuity
that causes the MMMNA to be in excess of the MMMNA ($1493 or $2267 in hardship cases)
3). The return on the annuity over its lifetime exceeds the life expectancy of
the annuitant; then that portion of the annuity that exceeds the annuitant's life
expectancy is counted as a transfer without fair consideration
4). The return on the annuity over its lifetime is less than the original
purchase price, the difference shall be considered a transfer without fair
consideration.
5). If an irrevocable annuity is purchased by the Medicaid applicant or the
community spouse and the return or the benefit is transferred to a third party,
the total amount of the annuity is a transfer without fair consideration.
For example: An straight life annuity (exempt resource) purchased by a 65
year old male for $40,000 pays $306 a month (the payment in this case is based on a
life expectancy of 15 years for a 65 year old male). However, the same annuity
purchased as a "15 year certain with life thereafter" is a non-exempt resource which pays $282 and is considered a transfer without fair consideration.
Since the annuitant is not maximizing the investment through a straight life annuity,
a transfer of assets without fair consideration exists for the difference between
the $306 and $282 payment. The difference in this case of $4,320 ($24 difference x
12 months x 15 years = $4,320) would be considered as a transfer of assets. This
would result in a transfer penalty period of one month (we divide the $4,320 by
$4,424 = approximately one month). The percentage is not counted in the calculation.
f. If a person makes a life estate after July 1, 1995, the transfer of title will
be considered a transfer without fair consideration. To figure the amount of the
transfer in the life estate:
1). Determine the equity value of the property at the time the life estate is
transferred (ie the sales price, the market value or the assessed value) minus any
liabilities, mortgages, or liens.
2). Multiply the equity value by the "remainder factor" that corresponds
to the person's age at the time the life estate is transferred using the following
table.
3). The result is the amount of property that is transferred without fair
consideration.
For example: If a 75-year-old individual sets up a life estate on January 2,
1999, and the actual value of the property is determined to be $75,000. To determine
the amount of transfer without fair consideration, multiply .47851 (taken from the
Life Estate Remainder Interest Table) by $75,000 which results in $35,888.25. For
1999, the penalty amount is $4,424 per month. The amount of time the individual would
not be eligible for Medicaid assistance ($35,888.25 divided by $4,424) is 8.11 or
almost 8 ½ months of ineligibility for Medicaid assistance from the date of the
transfer.
If the period of ineligibility for a transfer has already been served, it will
not be added to the other transfers. For example, an individual transferred $4,000
on March 31 and $10,000 on May 1. An application for Medicaid is placed on May 10.
The transfer penalty for March has already been served before the May transfer
occurs ($4,000 divided by $4,424 = .90. The calculation begins on March 1 (the
first day of the month in which the transfer occurred) and would end prior to March
31. In this case, only the $10,000 transferred in May would be used to calculate
the transfer penalty.
d. There is no maximum period of ineligibility. If an individual transferred
$100,000 on March 20, the total penalty period would be 22.60 months of ineligibility
starting from the date of the transfer ($100,000 divided by $4,424 = 22.60 months).
NOTE: if the application for Medicaid is made after the penalty period has expired,
there will not be a problem applying for Medicaid.
e. The exact period of disqualification is determined by dividing the amortization
rate (currently $4,424) into the amount of transfer. This will result in a
disqualification period that will usually be a whole number with a percent after
it (ie 3.07). The three represents the number of months and the .07 represents a
number of days within the month. To determine the number of days the .07 represents,
multiply the .07 by 30 (used as a standard month). In the example given, the number
of days is 2 (.17 x 30 = 2.10 days - any decimal is dropped). This leaves a total
disqualification of 3 months and 2 days calculated from the date of the transfer.
f. The period of ineligibility may be waived if a "hardship" is determined by the
county. A hardship may be considered if the following conditions as given in State
Manual section 8.110.54, #9 are met:
1). the individual has no alternative living arrangement other than the nursing home;
2). all resources through the transfer have been irretrievably lost;
3). the county department may apply other hardship criteria to other situations
that are deemed as a valid hardship.